Friday, 10 February 2012

John’s Blog No.61 – Pensions- The Way Forward Economically

Pension reform could play and be a major part in the economic recovery from the present recession, and arises from the large amounts of money that would be released into investment infrastructure in the economy.
The proposed new Universal pension scheme would involve 50% of the working population who have made no previous saving in pensions, even restricting this to age 25 to 44 still gives some 8.5 million new savers. At an average total contribution of £1,600 per year this gives annual fund addition of £13.64 billion, which could be doubled by the NI rebate to £27 billion per year.
If all of this were invested in infrastructure, it should not be difficult to meet a 6% return, which would itself be invested and effectively frees any project of Capital return during the construction/ investment stage.
It would be essential for maximum economic impact in the UK that the majority of this money is retained within the UK, i.e. spent here, particularly in the early years. This would have a major economic impact, creating jobs and growth spread over a wide range of skills and ages and would need careful planning.
There are many areas where this spend could occur in a positive beneficial way and which are urgently needed and slowed down by present spending cuts and investment starvation. Affordable Housing, Schools, Hospitals, Care homes, Transport, Energy and various High-tech R&D areas ready for implementation are all good examples.
 The majority of these in the early stages are labour intensive and use materials and skills available here such as bricks, mortar, concrete, steel etc. and our manufacturing capability could be built up to meet a good part of the equipment needs of the second phase.
Most of the project have timescales ranging from several up to 10 years, with expenditure spread over this period; over ten years the pension funds available in real terms with interest would amount to some £350 billion plus.
It needs little imagination to visualise what such spend would do both to growth and basic structure of the UK.
  • The ill conceived HS2 at £32bn could be replaced by a 1200 mile advanced vacuum network linking all the major cities, which even with rolling stock would leave £12bn+ for major electrification work elsewhere.
  • The Severn Barrage at £32bn would create employment from the West Country, Wales up to N.Ireland and solve our green energy needs.
  • A  Water grid; Broadband highway; Gas grid and major sewer, water and electricity work
  • A million affordable homes should cost some £60 billion, 1.000 schools and hospitals could be similar.
  • This would still leave some £120bn for other projects and investment in roads, Hi-tech etc.
All in the first ten years, with another ten before the first pensions become due.
There is the opportunity to recapture the spirit and endeavour shown in the 19th and early 20th Century and the social responsibility, which pulled millions out of extreme poverty into a more comfortable existence. We live in an exciting era with technical advances equivalent to those occurring in that time.
W e need to face up to the challenge and grasp the opportunities firmly but this will not occur without major changes to the current social structure and our attitude to change, plus positive vision in approach.
Comment Footnote – It was reported this week that over the past six months, annuity rates have dropped by a third; someone retiring has therefore lost a third of 40 years of hard earned pension savings, effectively “stolen by a forced sale. This money still exists to be realised by its new owner and shows the stupidity, dishonesty, speculative and unacceptable nature of the present pension system. It will be a major problem in Nest, be very much afraid as all will soon be involved in this modern form of highway robbery.
Time for a change is well overdue and requires positive action to guarantee, protect and safeguard the personal pension savings of all in the UK. It is our pension future and the State as well as the individual has as much to gain.  
Annuities, Public Sector, NHS, Teachers, Police, Local Government, Hutton, State Pensions, Transport, Comment


Friday, 3 February 2012

John’s Blog No.60 – Pensions-The Way Forward 3

We outlined in the two previous blogs the basis for a new universal pension scheme, which if implemented would have major beneficial effects on the working and retired population and the UK as a whole. It would
·         Guarantee all in work a pension proportional to contributions made with a minimum acceptable basic level and modest contributions
·         Relate State expenditure to a fixed percentage of NI income aimed at 50%
·         Allow flexible retirement before or at the present 65 level or beyond if preferred.
·         Allow major annual investment Fund spend to promote Economic growth, Employment and prosperity
·         Create Pension Funds large enough to give stability and security over the long saving period, with fund continuity through work and retirement
·         Give all members a defined Pension pot, retained for the rest of their life
·         Generate sufficient Fund surpluses to meet elderly care, social needs and quality of retirement
·         Allow sufficient redistribution of pension wealth to guarantee the lower paid an adequate pension
·         Clearly separate and define welfare for those incapable of work, as a responsibility of the State
 This may sound a Pension Utopia but is readily possible with will, determination and strength of purpose, combined with vision and good management.
The money is already being saved and spent in pensions, it just needs organising and control to give maximum benefit and value for money. For example if the £55bn spent annually on the basic State pension was invested over 40 years at a modest 4% return it would yield a pension spend of £200bn per year, giving a BSP of £370 pw.
Unfortunately it is locked in the unfunded system distortion, paying today’s pensions for people who thought wrongly that their NI contributions were being saved for their own retirement and this continues ad nauseum.
It is time to break this viscous circle, treat contributions as personal savings, accrued for  their benefit, with all the advantages this entails; the proposals outlined offer a cost neutral way of doing this.
It is not suggested that it will be easy or not involve political u-turns, particularly in Public Sector pensions, who require the same change; or not involve changes in investment attitude and practice.
The present Financial markets cannot meet the demands of long term saving of stability, fairness and guarantee, they are too involved in fast buck, quick profits and basic greed. Modest slow and steady growth gives adequate returns over 40 year plus with a modicum of risk and higher returns in the early years.
Our Victorian Ancestors showed determination, vision and long term investment, grasping opportunities, to leave us a legacy of infrastructure which has lasted 150 years and which we are struggling to repair or replace. We need to follow their example and rediscover their spirit.
Unfortunately we are stagnating, without firm or strong leadership, stumbling from pillar to post often with two steps back for each one forward, saturated with idealism with realism forgotten or ignored. Meanwhile the Far East have adopted the Victorian zeal and attitude and steadily leaving us behind.
Before we become the Commonwealth countries of China, we must stop the self flagellation of blame, woe and  despondency and take common sense steps to ensure our future, whether it be an insular UK or a realistic and sensible part of the Global economy, where we recognise and accept our place and relative importance.  
Pension reform offers the means to do this and secure our retirement and economic future.
 Annuities, Public Sector, NHS, Teachers, Police, Local Government, Hutton, State Pensions, Transport, Comment

Wednesday, 1 February 2012

John’s Blog No. 59b – Comment

It is now a month since we entered the New Year and little has changed on possible good intentions
Executive Pay and Bonuses – are still unresolved with mind staggering figures being quoted. In a responsible Society it somehow seems obscene that someone can earn in a year what a person on average wage needs a lifetime to achieve.
The present Century has seen an escalation in Executive and Management pay to levels unprecedented in earlier years and out of all proportion to normal wages and work justification. It is argued as a matter of worth to our leaders of Industry, major Institutions and Local Councils, but what worth and at what cost.
The average wage in the UK is currently £25,800 per year, is this management worth four, six or even ten times those who work hard in the business and help to create that wealth. Even these factors do not approach the 40 to 200 times the average wage that these people assess themselves at.
Many of the worst offenders in the Financial Industry run no more than a large casino gambling our money and livelihood away, others ruin perfectly good businesses by denying working capital or asset stripping. Yet the basic financiers, the shareholders who take the risk, see their money disappear in falling share prices as a result of these astute management efforts.
Benefit Control – on the other end of the scale, we see a very similar position amongst a large number of those on benefit. Both Houses are arguing over a benefit cap, needed to control the runaway costs, yet this is intended to encourage a return to work, but is set at a level above the average wage!
 A person on the average wage will pay tax and NI amounting to some £5,600 and will have work costs, pension contributions, etc., which will bring take home pay below £19,000. Yet there are no proposals in the £26,000 benefit cap that include tax or NI deductions, making recipients some £7,000 per year better off not working.
At the other end of the scale, pensioners are expected to live on £5,300 or £8,400 if a couple. The minimum the State says a person needs to live on is set at £6,600  and even if we apply these more generous levels, allowing for children we arrive at benefit cap levels below £14,000, giving adequate income and leaving incentive to work.
High Speed Trains – another area which has been kicked into touch, but the more one looks into it the more it appears as a colossal waste of money, creating disruption and upset for many.
In addition to the normal arguments against, it would seem that it could be out dated before it even starts running, The Chinese are working on a Vactrain, which they say can be put into operation in ten years. It would run in a vacuum tube at speeds of 620 mph, which could increase up to 5,000 mph and with no air resistance, consumes little energy.
Such a virtual perpetual motion machine offers obvious advantage although costs are expected to be higher than HS2.
There is however a much lower cost opportunity in vacuum transport using smaller car size capsules running in five foot diameter tubes with speeds of 340 mph, but capable of much higher speeds. Cars would take six passengers or 600kgm of freight in an automated dual tubeway claimed to have the capacity of a 32 lane highway and cost one tenth of HS2.
The concept is not new, as a child, I can remember my mother paying the assistant in a store, who put the money and sale ticket in a twist lock capsule and inserted it into a vacuum tube. I listened fascinated as it went up to and along the ceiling to the office and within a minute or so returned dropping into a tray with change and receipt.
Thousands of miles of gas pipelines exist up to four feet in diameter, buried just underground in excavated trenches and even under sea, at costs from £ 2 to 3.5 million per mile, including terminals and pumping stations. Dual tubeways should therefore cost £7 to 8 million per mile, making London to Birmingham (25 minutes) less than £1bn, in fact a 1200 mile tubeway linking all major cities in UK mainland would only cost one third of HS2 plus rolling stock.
The prospect of travelling in a vacuum may be daunting, but in fact a major part of modern travel is carried out this way in aircraft. Capsules should cost less than cars with no engines, once accelerated to speed they would then coast without power. Linear motor and Maglev trains exist or rail or coil gun techniques could be used, to get 1,000 kgms up to 340mph, which requires 3.1Kwh of energy in half a minute timescale.
The UK has the opportunity to be at the forefront of such green and advanced technology.
Public Sector Pensions – have gone quiet but are rumbling on with the government forcing its unfair round one proposals on to teachers and nurses, this will be an annual event with growing unrest and dissatisfaction.
   Annuities Public Sector  NHS  Teachers  Police  Local Government  Hutton State Pensions Transport Comment

Saturday, 28 January 2012

John’s Blog No 59 – Pensions - The Way Forward 2

There are many aspects of contributory pension that appear to have been forgotten or lost; these are the pension yield factor, which allows easy assessment; the annuity gain in which a 4% return allows a 6% payment resulting in the fact that Pension funds do not have to be repaid but only serviced at a modest 4%.
These can all be used to allow the cost neutral transition of the State unfunded schemes to the more beneficial funded ones provided new money is available. The existing and future pensions are a State liability, which in 2004 were given at £1200bn and are now probably twice that.
In the UK, 75% of the working age population of age 16 to 64 are in work (some 29 million), 25% belong to pension schemes and 50% make no other provision outside State NI, the balance are students, housewives unemployed, disabled and early retired, who will depend on welfare.
There is little point in envying those in defined benefit schemes, we should all aim to join them in a fair and value for money system reflecting our personal savings and hard work. The State should concentrate on pension welfare.
It is clear that at least half the working age population need an attractive pension scheme to ensure their retirement future. It is apparent that BSP or NEST will not fulfil this need or give value for money, hence the need for personal contributions. The State should also do their share in the guarantee of pension income from NI.
The current state spend on BSP is £55bn, which is over half NI income and roughly equals average individual contribution of 8 to 10%, hence the proposed 8% rebate tied to 50% NI income. To survive, it is essential that State  expenditure is linked to income and this can only be achieved through a funded scheme.
Over the next 40 years the over 65 population is projected to double, together with real costs which are clearly unaffordable and short term measures of delayed retirement etc. will not meet these costs, resulting in more taxation.
Time is an essential factor in a funded scheme, needed to allow savings to accumulate and grow into a fund sufficient to meet the demands of retirement and to survive with its owner, 40 years is an ideal length with 20 years the minimum.
 With retirement at 65, this makes age 25 a good starting point; studying is usually complete and wages have stabilised allowing affordable savings to be started; it is also difficult after age 45 to build up adequate funds.
The 20 year transition allows time for the new scheme to become established and build up funds; after this time pensions from 45+ will become due and need to be met and it is also proposed that the new and existing schemes take responsibility for all new pensions that become due thereafter, including BSP.
It can be shown that a £1,000bn State pension bond or asset transfer yielding 4% will meet the 45+ pension and population liability. This would release a third of current BSP spend for NI rebate, providing new money is available to meet the 2% shortfall.
The new money could come from asset income, rent or by the build up of new pension bond, sold to the new scheme, effectively the new scheme using contributions or NI rebate as part of fund investment. Over the first ten years BSP spend would need to increase with population and inflation and during the next move to match NI income proportion.
Such a transition is possible with major advantages to all concerned, starting with new scheme members and moving to established schemes later, with State liability eventually fixed at 50 to 60% NI income and members gaining from a funded defined benefit scheme with a guaranteed pension outcome related to savings input.
The member’s Pension contribution savings will be affordable and multiplied by four from Employer, Tax relief and NI rebate with final pension replacement some 4 to 6 times total annual contributions and 16 to 24 those of members. Good scheme management should generate sufficient funds to give pensions of at least 50% wage and allow redistribution to lower earners and elderly care needs.
   Annuities         Public Sector   NHS         Teachers   Police   Local Government    Hutton   State Pensions

Saturday, 21 January 2012

John’s Blog no 58 – Pensions - The Way Forward

Over the past blogs we have developed the needs and basics of pensions and it is now time to convert these into positive proposals. This was covered in an early blog which outlined a Universal funded defined benefit pension scheme whose aim was to bring everyone in work up to the same degree of excellence as the best schemes available today.
The only way to meet the projected onslaught of the increasing over 65 population is pension self sufficiency in which everyone who works carries his own pension pot into retirement, adequate for his needs. These must be treated and protected as personal savings, each with their own name tag and share of the overall fund.
However it is essential that the major advantages of size is not lost, including those of annuity type payments, as this gives Commercial strength both in continuity and fund returns. Funds should also stay alive, but separated, after retirement, not to be replaced by insurance or other promissory notes, which is a major weakness of existing schemes.
Plans are in hand for a single state pension of £140 per week to replace BSP, S2P and SERPS, and also a new NEST contributory scheme starting in September. Both are flawed and will not meet the needs and challenges facing pension provision. The new level is still below the current welfare pension plus other benefits, and Nest is based on defined contributions shown by DWP to lose money in real terms.
It is time for a new radical approach and this is made possible by combining the two approaches; to replace the State pension with an NI rebate incorporating NEST for all in work not making any self-provision .
This contributory UFDB scheme would take the proposed 4% members contribution plus the 3% employer and 1% tax relief and match it with an 8% NI rebate, effectively increasing members contributions by a factor four. The scheme would guarantee a minimum pension in today’s terms of £140 pw to all in work, which is increased by members contributions and increases with inflation assumed at 2.5%.
 For example if we take the average female wage of £400 pw, this would earn a guaranteed £140 pw plus an additional £116 pw, in total £256 pw all for member contributions of only £16 pw over a 40 year savings period in real terms. Total contributions are £64 pw requiring a pension yield factor of four and a modest investment return just over 4%.
 This is a good return for a very small outlay and should therefore be attractive, an offer too good to miss, it also takes account of worst case population rises; retains existing retirement age; with a secure outcome and sufficient flexibility to allow earlier retirement or larger pensions with extra contributions. It also has the advantage of a visible pension return on NI contributions, rather than the present “begging bowl” State benefit approach.
The main problem is the transition from the existing State position to an independent scheme in a cost neutral way for State expenditure. Existing pensions and welfare payments take all and more of the current NI income and these have to be met besides finding the money for rebate, which is where the new contributions take effect.
In the transition stage it needs to be a compromise between the State, the new scheme and existing pension schemes meeting the existing pensions; one way is effectively investing the NI rebate in State pension bonds to finance them and taking over new pensions as they arise after the 20 year transition.
In order to allow the new scheme and its members to build up funds, eligible entry is restricted to age 25 to 44, building up to 64 over the twenty years when the first new pensions become due, this also reduces the NI rebate to more reasonable and affordable amounts. This also fits in with the 25 to 64 memberships criteria, allowing 40 year saving.
 The overall aim is to give a scheme which is attractive and fair to all, whose guaranteed returns reflect the contributions paid with a minimum safety level, which is flexible enough to meet changing needs and situations and to meet the long term challenge of ageing population and pension provision in the 21st century.
The advantages of the proposed system stretch well beyond the provision of pensions and could have far reaching economic effects; the State no longer has liability for pension provision, except for welfare, and NI rebate cost are linked firmly to NI income. This results in savings in State expenditure reaching £30bn or more in real terms, in addition funds for investment amounting to £60bn+ annually become available to allow infrastructure and other expenditure to boost jobs and prosperity, besides improving living standards.
The next blog will put more flesh on the basic bones outlined today from the build up of funds to the problems of the cost of meeting existing pensions and the money generated to meet benefits.
Savings   Annuities          Public Sector   NHS         Teachers   Police   Local Government    Hutton   State Pensions

Thursday, 12 January 2012

John’s Blog No 55b –Pensions – Comment on New Year

The first week of 2012 has been busy with lots of New Year’s resolutions in Politics, Business and all in influence, of course what we really want is a NY revolution in thinking, approach and action.
There is no real leadership in the UK; Cameron blows with the wind, seizing on the latest Public Opinion; Clegg has disappeared, as a lifelong Liberal I find little to support; and Milliband does not exist, not that you can notice. In fact there is little leadership in the World today, except for China and various dictatorships.
Anyway if we look at the various events of the past week, not in any particular order.
Breast Implants  - These are faulty goods, not fit for purpose and should be treated in the same way as anything else we buy. With all the stringent control on drugs, how on earth did they get on the market, five minutes testing with modern analysis would have shown them up as industrial silicone! Surely the clinics have insurance to cover this.
HS2 – The case is based on increased capacity, business need and job creation. Due to the braking distances required and the laws of physics, doubling the speed increase the train spacing four times thus halving the capacity and needs dedicated lines without slower traffic. Motorway experience shows that at peak times reducing the speed to 50mph, smooths out the flow and reduces travel times, we have all experienced the stop start travel surges on busy motorways and the delays.
Business needs- the 25 minutes saved on travel times will be spent in delays getting to the station, the logistics of waiting to board and delays getting to the final destination. Modern technology allows one still to work, deal with e-mails, video conference or just sit back and enjoy the countryside on a slightly longer journey.
On previous experience job creation will certainly occur in Germany, France, etc. but how much will really be spent here; it is another way of increasing our balance of payments deficit, as if we need one.
It will go down in history as an epic waste of money, there are better ways of spending £33bn; the Severn barrage would do more lasting good and meet green targets, as would Housing, School, Hospitals and modernising all  infrastructure generally, they all would  create more jobs and boost the economy and prosperity.
 Immigration-“ does not displace British workers except from outside the UK”. Commonsense and observation shows this to be not true, based on those who draw benefit it is obviously flawed, how many EU or other immigrants even exist officially, pay tax have an NI number or work permits. They are visitor workers outside rules, who export money home, they are industrious with a good work attitude which we could well adopt.
Directors pay and Banking reform – still in the doldrums and unresolved, including bonuses; pay should be related to share value and other perks such as share issue and bonuses should be banned; shareholders, employees and all concerned should obviously have a greater say. This would give better value for money, it is debateable whether such high incomes in any occupation are deserved, earned or worthwhile.
Economy – “There is a good time coming but it’s ever so far away” seems to be the theme tune, but the credit squeeze does not make sense. It started off with good intentions, a 20% cut to get things straight, but then someone appears to have been too lazy to sort the detail or think it through.
The result is the easy way out, cut services; shed labour to cut wages; close libraries and community centres; cut grants to charities etc., regardless of whether they are doing a useful job or essential to communities or a necessity to maintain an ordered society and even whether you can afford to be without it.
However it is funny how the odd billion can be found for something or other and we spend money wildly abroad, we need to balance budgets but mainly on our external budgets with the rest of the world.
Olympics – dominate the headlines, the ticket fiasco continues; like the budget spend, they seem to find the odd million or so tucked away; are they filling the tracks with seats or can no one count. The cost rises steadily, now its security, which we were assured had been catered for, but apparently not. It is also puzzling that no mention of parking facilities for cars and coaches has taken place, or is that another jack-in the box waiting to jump out.
Youth – has also been in the news after the riots, but they were only a mindless minority; there is a lot to be admired in the youth of today, they have modern technology at their fingertips and seem to have more get up and go than I can remember from my youth. What they need is more opportunity, they have no work, nowhere to go, nothing to do and if they want to better themselves at University, a lifetime mortgage. Other Countries, especially the successful ones, value and nurture their youth, perhaps we should follow their example.
The New Years Resolution I would like is a little bit more common sense and thought in planning our future.
Savings   Annuities          Public Sector   NHS         Teachers   Police   Local Government    Hutton   State Pensions

Friday, 6 January 2012

John’s Blog 55 – Pensions – Simplified 8 – How Much

The main question of course is how much; what income is needed to live on in retirement? what does one need to put aside and what fund is required to sustain that income? It is a little like how long is a piece of string, but one can have a good guess and come up with some reasonable answers.
Starting with the easy bit, what income?, if you take your latest pay slip, or slips for a working couple, then take pay after all deductions, including pension contributions, deduct mortgage costs, estimate work and children costs and that is what you are basically living on at present.
One needs to work in real terms, that is today’s living costs and assume income and savings value match inflation, to readily understand and relate the figures, as one is looking at long time scales of 40 to 60 years.
There are many figures available on what income is spent and required to maintain an adequate living standard and we shall deal with the lower end at and above the welfare level, as the rest tends to take care of itself. This is not directly related to wage level, at the average part time wage of £200 per week, £10,000 pa, the normal 50% i.e. half final salary is below the poverty level.
Of course the final income depends on living styles and age, if you retire at 55 with some 20 years of active life you will want to travel and spend on hobbies, sport, leisure activities etc., at 65 to a lesser extent and 75 and above this expenditure can reduce substantially. A comfortable level has been put at £14,000 pa.
We have the absurd position that the basic State pension is currently £102 pw, but the minimum the State says a single person needs to live on (Pension credit) is 30% higher at £130, effectively the poverty level.
It is proposed to increase BSP to £140 pw but do away with the State second pension and SERPS, which would make National Insurance contributions meaningless. The basic problem is that BSP is treated as a charitable State benefit and not as a working right and therefore degraded beyond benefit levels.
Effectively all pensioners will live below the poverty level unless they make savings / contributions for an additional pension now being introduced as the NEST scheme later this year, basically paying twice for your pension. This is a defined contribution scheme with no guarantees and traditionally poor returns with an expected PYF of 1.9 well below inflation proofed values at 2.4.
On the average female wage of £20,000 pa, contributions at 8% will be £1,600 with an expected pension of £3,000, even at 4% return it should be £5,700 and at 6% should be as high as £9,000. However contributions from NI are almost the same amount, doubled by Employers yielding £5,300, so there must be a better way.
This will be explored in the next blog with a radical new approach to pension provision.
Savings   Annuities          Public Sector   NHS         Teachers   Police   Local Government    Hutton   State Pensions